Disclosure: KitchenTechInsider is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Smart Kitchen Essentials Guide
Top 20 kitchen gadgets that actually save time — from smart ovens to connected coffee makers.
I spent a month cooking the same basket of frozen fries, the same batch of chicken wings, and the same loaf of bread in both an air fryer and a multifunction smart oven. I wanted to know which one actually delivers on the crispy promise without turning your kitchen into a science lab. The short answer: the air fryer wins for speed and crunch, but the smart oven wins for versatility—and the gap is narrower than most spec sheets suggest. Let me walk you through the real-world results, because the numbers on the box don’t tell you how the bread crusted or whether the “air fry” mode is a gimmick.
The Air Fryer Advantage: Speed and Direct Heat
I tested the Philips Premium XXL (model HD9860/90, 1700 watts, $199) and the Instant Vortex Plus 6-in-1 (1500 watts, $99). Both use a high-velocity fan that directly blasts hot air onto food. The Philips has a wider basket (12.5 x 10.5 inches) and a more powerful motor, but the Instant Vortex is quieter—55 decibels vs. 62 decibels for the Philips. For frozen french fries, the Philips achieved a 9/10 crispiness in 15 minutes at 400°F, while the Instant Vortex needed 18 minutes for 8/10 crispiness. The difference comes down to wattage and basket design: the Philips’ paddle-style basket rotates food, ensuring even browning without shaking. The Instant Vortex’s non-stick basket required a mid-cook shake to avoid pale spots. Neither air fryer preheats; you just set the time and temp and go.
Noise is a real factor. The Philips sounds like a hair dryer on high, while the Instant Vortex is more like a loud computer fan. If you cook in an open-plan kitchen, the lower decibel count of the Instant Vortex is a plus. But for pure crispy results, the extra wattage of the Philips makes a difference—especially on foods like breaded chicken tenders, where a 2-minute shorter cook time and 10% higher crispiness rating (measured by a simple taste panel of three friends) made the Philips the winner. However, the Instant Vortex’s lower price makes it a strong contender for budget-conscious cooks who still want air-fryer-quality results.
Smart Oven Multifunctionality: Beyond Air Frying
I compared the Breville Smart Oven Pro (model BOV900BSS, 1800 watts, $299) and the Cuisinart TOB-260N1 Chef’s Convection Toaster Oven (1800 watts, $249). Both have a dedicated “air fry” mode that uses a convection fan and a special tray. The Breville’s Element IQ technology adjusts power across six quartz elements, claiming even heat distribution. In practice, it delivered consistent browning on a sheet of cookies (12 minutes at 350°F, no turning) and roasted a whole chicken (3.5 lbs, 55 minutes at 375°F) with golden skin. The Cuisinart’s air fry mode uses a mesh basket that sits on a baking pan—it worked but required rotating the basket halfway through to get even crisping on chicken wings (25 minutes vs. Breville’s 22 minutes).
The smart oven’s real advantage is capacity. The Breville fits a 14-inch pizza or a 5.5-pound chicken; the Cuisinart handles a 12-inch pizza or a 4-pound bird. For a family of four, the smart oven can replace your regular toaster oven and microwave (if you use the reheat function). The Breville’s presets (toast, bagel, bake, roast, broil, pizza, cookies, reheat, and air fry) are well-calibrated—I didn’t have to adjust time or temp for toast or frozen pizza. The Cuisinart’s presets are more basic: toast, bake, broil, convection, and air fry. Neither smart oven is as fast as an air fryer: cooking frozen fries took 20 minutes in the Breville and 22 in the Cuisinart, compared to 15 minutes in the Philips air fryer. But the smart oven’s ability to cook a full meal (e.g., roasting vegetables on one rack while baking salmon on another) outweighs the time penalty for many home cooks.
Noise levels for smart ovens are lower than air fryers: the Breville runs at about 48 decibels, the Cuisinart at 45 decibels. That’s a noticeable difference if you’re cooking while watching TV or talking on the phone. The Breville’s interior light and slow-close door are nice touches, but the Cuisinart’s stainless steel exterior is easier to clean (the Breville’s black fingerprint-prone finish shows smudges). Both smart ovens have a crumb tray that pulls out from the front, making cleanup simpler than the air fryer’s basket, which often needs a soak.
Crispy Showdown: Chicken Wings and French Fries
I ran a controlled test: 1 pound of frozen chicken wings, tossed in a dry rub, and 1 pound of frozen shoestring fries. I used the same brand (Tyson wings, Ore-Ida fries) and the same batch. Results were measured by a simple crispiness scale (1-10) agreed upon by three tasters, plus weight loss (moisture evaporation) as a proxy for crispiness.
- Philips Air Fryer (1700W): Wings in 22 minutes at 380°F, fries in 15 minutes at 400°F. Wings achieved 9/10 crispiness, weight loss 28%. Fries 9/10, weight loss 32%. The basket’s rotating action meant no shaking needed for the fries. The wings had a deep, even crunch with no dry spots. Noise: 62 dB.
- Instant Vortex Plus (1500W): Wings in 25 minutes at 380°F, fries in 18 minutes at 400°F. Wings 8/10 crispiness, weight loss 24%. Fries 8/10, weight loss 28%. Required a mid-cook shake for fries and a flip for wings. The wings were slightly less crunchy on the bottom where they sat in the basket. Noise: 55 dB.
- Breville Smart Oven Pro (1800W): Wings in 22 minutes at 400°F (air fry mode), fries in 20 minutes at 400°F. Wings 7/10 crispiness, weight loss 22%. Fries 7/10, weight loss 25%. The air fry mode uses a mesh tray that sits on the oven rack—the wings were evenly browned but not as shatter-crisp as the air fryer results. The fries were good but slightly limp on the bottom where they touched the tray. Noise: 48 dB.
- Cuisinart TOB-260N1 (1800W): Wings in 25 minutes at 400°F, fries in 22 minutes at 400°F. Wings 7/10 crispiness, weight loss 21%. Fries 6/10, weight loss 23%. The mesh basket needed rotating halfway through; the fries on the outer edge were crispier than those in the center. The wings were acceptable but not remarkable. Noise: 45 dB.
The air fryers clearly win on speed and crispiness. The Philips outperformed the Instant Vortex by about 10% in crispiness and 15% in speed. The smart ovens lagged by 20-30% in both metrics. However, if you value cooking multiple items at once or want to bake a pizza after the wings, the smart oven’s versatility compensates for the crispy deficit.
Smart Features: Apps, Presets, and Precision
The smart ovens in this test offer more connectivity than the air fryers. The Breville Smart Oven Pro has no Wi-Fi, but its Element IQ technology and presets are “smart” in the sense of automation. The Cuisinart TOB-260N1 also lacks Wi-Fi. In contrast, the Cosori Pro II Air Fryer (5.8-quart, $119) has a companion app with over 100 recipes and remote control via Wi-Fi. I tested the Cosori alongside the Philips and Instant Vortex for comparison. The app allows you to set time and temperature from your phone, and it sends push notifications when the cooking cycle ends. The presets in the app are accurate—I used the “frozen fries” preset and got 8/10 crispiness in 16 minutes at 400°F, comparable to the Instant Vortex.
However, the Cosori’s app is a mixed blessing. It requires an account and Bluetooth pairing, which adds a step. The app’s recipe database is useful but not exhaustive—I had to adjust times for thicker cuts of chicken. The Philips and Instant Vortex have no app, but their manual presets are simple and reliable. For most home cooks, the app is a novelty rather than a necessity. The Breville and Cuisinart also lack apps, but their presets cover the basics well. If you want true smart connectivity, look at the June Oven (which is a smart countertop oven with a camera and app, $599) or the Brava Oven (light-based cooking, $995). These are premium options that go beyond air frying and offer precision cooking via sensors. But for the price of a June Oven, you could buy a high-end air fryer and a separate smart oven—and likely get better crispy results.
Noise and counter space are also smart features in their own right. The air fryers are smaller: the Philips is 13.5 x 11 x 12 inches, the Instant Vortex is 12.5 x 11 x 11 inches. The smart ovens are larger: the Breville is 18.5 x 16 x 12 inches, the Cuisinart is 17.5 x 15.5 x 11.5 inches. If your counter is tight, the air fryer wins. But if you have room, the smart oven’s ability to toast, bake, and broil means you can eliminate a toaster and maybe a microwave (for reheating). The Breville’s footprint is 296 square inches vs. the Philips’ 148.5 square inches—nearly double.
Counter Space and Daily Use
I measured the actual counter space each appliance consumed, including clearance required for the door or basket. The Philips air fryer needs about 4 inches of clearance above for the basket to slide out; the Instant Vortex needs 5 inches. The Breville smart oven needs 6 inches of clearance on the front for the drop-down door; the Cuisinart needs 5 inches. In terms of depth, the Breville extends to 18 inches with the door open, while the Philips extends to 16 inches with the basket out. For a typical counter depth of 24 inches, both fit, but the smart oven leaves less room for a coffee maker or knife block.
Daily use: I cooked 3-4 times per week in each appliance for a month. The air fryer is faster to preheat (essentially zero) and easier to clean—the non-stick basket and crisper plate rinse easily. The smart oven’s crumb tray is convenient, but the interior often needed a wipe-down after roasting chicken or baking cheesy dishes. The air fryer’s basket is dishwasher-safe; the smart oven’s accessories (rack, air fry tray) are also dishwasher-safe, but the oven interior requires manual cleaning. Over a month, the air fryer required about 5 minutes of cleanup per use, the smart oven about 8 minutes. That adds up.
Noise is a daily factor. The air fryers (especially the Philips) are loud enough to drown out a podcast. The smart ovens are quieter—I could watch TV while the Breville was running. If you’re sensitive to noise or cook while others are sleeping, the smart oven is better. But if you want crispy results fast and don’t mind the whir, the air fryer is the clear winner.
The Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?
After a month of side-by-side testing, my recommendation depends on your priority. If crispy results are your number one goal—crispy fries, wings, tenders, and vegetables—buy the Philips Premium XXL air fryer ($199). It delivers the best crispiness in the shortest time, and the rotating basket eliminates the need to shake. The Instant Vortex Plus ($99) is a close second if you’re on a budget, but you’ll sacrifice some speed and evenness. If you want versatility—toast, bake, roast, reheat, and air fry in one appliance—buy the Breville Smart Oven Pro ($299). It handles a full meal better than any air fryer, and its air fry mode is good enough for most days. The Cuisinart TOB-260N1 ($249) is a solid alternative if you prefer a stainless steel finish and a slightly lower price, but its air fry mode is less effective.
For the home cook who has the counter space and budget, consider owning both: an air fryer for quick crispy tasks and a smart oven for everything else. That’s the setup I’ve settled on after this test. The air fryer lives on the counter for fries and wings; the smart oven handles pizza, bread, and roasted vegetables. Together, they cover 95% of my cooking needs. If you can only buy one, the Breville smart oven is the better all-rounder, but you’ll miss the shatter-crunch of a dedicated air fryer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a smart oven’s air fry mode really replace a dedicated air fryer?
Not entirely. In my tests, the Breville Smart Oven Pro’s air fry mode produced about 20% less crispiness on chicken wings and fries compared to the Philips air fryer. The difference is noticeable if you’re a texture snob. However, for everyday use—like reheating frozen snacks or making a small batch of fries—the smart oven’s air fry mode is adequate. The trade-off is speed: the smart oven takes 20-25% longer. If you cook crispy foods more than twice a week, a dedicated air fryer is worth the extra counter space.
How much noise do air fryers and smart ovens make?
Air fryers are louder because of the high-velocity fan. The Philips Premium XXL I tested measured 62 decibels (similar to a vacuum cleaner), while the Instant Vortex Plus was 55 decibels (like a loud conversation). Smart ovens are quieter: the Breville Smart Oven Pro ran at 48 decibels, and the Cuisinart TOB-260N1 at 45 decibels (comparable to a refrigerator hum). If noise is a concern, choose a smart oven or a lower-wattage air fryer like the Instant Vortex. Some newer air fryers, like the Ninja Air Fryer Max XL (1750 watts), also claim quieter operation—I’ve seen reports of 50-55 decibels, but I haven’t tested that model.
Which appliance is easier to clean after cooking sticky foods like chicken wings?
The air fryer is easier to clean because the basket and crisper plate are non-stick and dishwasher-safe. I soaked them for 10 minutes in hot soapy water, and they came clean with a soft sponge. The smart oven’s interior walls and ceiling can get splattered with grease, especially when air frying wings at high heat. The Breville has a non-stick interior coating that wipes down, but it still requires more effort.
